| Year | K-12 | K-8 | K-5 | K-3 |
| 2025 | Skyler Bohannon & Luke Wojnicki | Leo Kusch & Nicholas Gabbard (“The Hawk-bats”) | Jude Wells & Hamilton Tanheimer | n/a |
| 2024 | Noah Bennet & Wade Wilson (North Bullit High School) | Alexa Beattie & Garrison Chandler (Hebron Middle School) | Jesse Kusch & Paul Kusch | David Barkley & Silas Matherly |
| 2023 | Nicholas Gabbard, Charles Hackman | Donovan Gee, Amir Elfarra | Beatrice Gabbard, Jude Wells | |
| 2022 | Nicholas Gabbard, Charles Hackman | Donovan Gee, Amir ??? |